Bureau of Forensic Medical Examination Tsaritsyno Kildushov. Cool magazine

The largest state morgue in Moscow was turned into a personal commercial enterprise

Russian funeral services traditionally prefer peace and tranquility. But under their mournful veil sometimes lie such dark secrets that one can only be amazed. One of these stories is closely connected with the head of the Bureau of Forensic Medicine of the city of Moscow, Evgeny Kildyushov, who managed to turn the largest state morgue into a personal commercial enterprise. Having taken over several “ritual” companies and concentrated the examination of Moscow dead in one place, Mr. Kildushov became, in fact, the uncrowned king of this coffin business.

Some time ago, the largest forensic morgue in Europe, Tsaritsyno, was built in Moscow, to which the bodies of the dead are delivered from all over the city.

The Bureau of Forensic Medicine, headed by Kildushov, is located in the same building. As other Moscow morgues close, Tsaritsyno takes over their load.

Despite the heavy workload of the morgue, in 2014 the funeral service there was liquidated, and its functions were taken over by businessmen from Angel LLC. As a result, a strange situation has arisen - forensic experts send relatives of the victims to this company, it collects money from them, and the preparation of corpses for burial, embalming and other services are performed by orderlies of the city morgue, during their working hours and for a budget salary. As a result, it is “Angel” who now actually and legally takes over all the turnover from ritual activities.

It is not surprising that most professionals who have worked in this system for decades chose to quit. Soon there was no one left in Tsaritsino who could prevent the morgue from becoming a source of enrichment for the cunning head of the bureau.

Another dubious “business” of the expert bureau and its head is the removal of internal organs from corpses. According to Russian legislation, this is permissible if the person did not prohibit such actions during his lifetime. But no matter how cynical it may sound, everything has a price, and human organs have a very specific cost. Through what channels the organs confiscated to Tsaritsyno go, where and for what money - remains a secret behind seven seals, carefully guarded by Mr. Kildyushov and his “colleagues”.

In August 2014, this story received a new continuation. The Moscow Department of Health issued an order to redistribute Moscow districts into branches of the Forensic Medical Examination Bureau - “in order to further improve the organization of forensic medical examination, rational and effective use of healthcare resources.” According to this order, the next forensic morgue is closed and all corpses will now be transferred to the Tsaritsyno morgue.

We are talking about morgue No. 16, opened due to numerous requests from the population of New Moscow. At first, corpses from new territories annexed to the capital arrived at the Tsaritsyno morgue, which was extremely inconvenient due to the remoteness, since each deceased person had relatives, including elderly ones, who wanted to see off a loved one on their last journey. But, according to the decision of the Department, in September judicial morgue No. 16 will cease to exist as an independent institution and will move to Tarny Proezd, to the Tsaritsyno morgue.

This is not the first reduction in the number of Moscow morgues. In the spring of this year, morgue No. 2, which was a kind of brand for Russian doctors, was closed. Entire generations of doctors from all over the country studied forensic medicine here! And Mr. Kildushov himself owes his career to this morgue!

Morgues are closed under various formal pretexts, under which, by the way, any morgue can be closed, and first of all the notorious “Tsaritsyno”. However, it is quite obvious that only those branches in which the interests of ritual organizations friendly to Mr. Kildushov are not represented are subject to closure. This, unfortunately, is a fact.

It is worth noting that, unlike the now closed morgues No. 2 and No. 16, in “Tsaritsyno” and some other divisions of the Bureau, through the efforts of Kildyushov himself and with the active participation of the deputy for economic affairs, former official of the Ministry of Health O.A. Doronina. Extra-budgetary activities have been organized to prepare the bodies of the dead for release, which is implemented through private ritual organizations. At the same time, Kildushov himself actively positions himself as having nothing to do with ritual services. Maybe. But then the question arises, why does Kildushov act contrary to common sense, the interests of the Bureau, destroying its infrastructure, and also contrary to the interests of ordinary people who are forced to go to the ends of the earth to bury their relatives, just like that, “for the love of art”? Or maybe this is proof that the actual head of the Bureau is Doronina, which has been discussed and written about for a long time? Well, we must give her credit - she deftly pulls the strings of her puppet!

The next candidate for closure was morgue No. 15, located in the city of Troitsk. After this, all of New Moscow will be forced to go to the Tsaritsino morgue, located in an industrial zone, far from traffic intersections. This is how greed overcomes common sense!

It is necessary to say a few words about the work of the Tsaritsyno complex itself. In addition to the already described extra-budgetary activities of the head of the Bureau of Forensic Medicine, there are other problems there. For example, among morgue employees, tuberculosis is flourishing as an occupational disease, caused by the huge number of incoming corpses, including those with a verified diagnosis of tuberculosis and HIV infection.

In one sectional hall "Tsaritsyno" about 20 corpses can be opened in one working day. Often, employees spend five hours a day there, and, despite the absence of any instructions in regulatory documents, in the sectional room the forensic medical expert must completely write a report on the forensic medical examination of the corpse, which also applies to persons who died from tuberculosis and HIV infection.

Corpses arriving from specialized hospitals, in order to comply with the formalities and legality of their presence in the morgue, arrive at Tsaritsyno as the bodies of unknown persons, although photocopies of the passports of the deceased are found in the medical records. In addition, the Tsaritsyno morgue receives putrefactive corpses from almost the entire territory of Moscow. We should also not forget that on the territory of the Tsaritsyno complex there is also a corpse storage facility. In all likelihood, the “rational and effective use of health care resources” consists of creating a kind of “city of the dead” on the territory of Moscow, which is a constant breeding ground for various types of infections and socially significant diseases.

Such responsible and unhealthy work should be paid accordingly. By order of the Department of Health, a point system of remuneration was urgently introduced into the practice of the Bureau, which had the appearance of some kind of fraudulent scheme. From January of this year to the present, this system has already changed five times, as a result the cost of a point has decreased from 1000 to 250 rubles. It is unknown how the cost of one point is calculated today, how money is distributed among departments and how it is awarded to specific individuals. It is not possible to obtain any clarification from the management of the SME Bureau. The Bureau has completely stopped paying replacements for sick leave and vacations, which is a violation of labor laws. Thus, there is a decrease in wages for ordinary employees.

The Moscow Bureau of Medical Examiners has a long history and has always been distinguished by its high quality of examinations, which completely satisfied the customer. With the arrival of Evgeniy Kildushov to the leadership of the bureau, the quality of examinations suddenly suddenly ceased to suit the administration. Numerous spontaneous unscheduled inspections began in the institution, introducing dissonance into the work of the departments. Very often, the requirements of one inspector contradict the requirements of another. Quality control of examinations carried out by the Bureau administration mainly comes down to checking the number of commas, paragraphs and font size, which does not in any way affect the true quality of examinations and the “conclusions” of experts. All claims to the quality of examinations are made verbally, are not regulated in any way, and in some places contradict the Code of Criminal Procedure, and therefore their elimination is impossible and leads to sabotage of the institution’s work.

At the same time, for the slightest offense, employees are often subject to unjustified disciplinary sanctions, leading to the cancellation of bonuses and incentive payments. Most of the Bureau's employees are already under one form of disciplinary action or another, which likely contributes to an increase in the wage savings fund, from which Kildushov himself and his associates receive bonuses that are not comparable to the salaries of ordinary employees.

The apogee of this situation was the verification of expert activities in the form of unstitching corpses in order to re-weigh organs and re-measure their sizes, without formalizing or providing any documents. The inspectors cannot answer the question about the legal aspects of these actions. But what about the dignified treatment of the body of the deceased, regulated by the Law on Funeral Business?

It must be said that this kind of frequent checks, and even more so the invention of various ridiculous requirements that interfere with normal work, and often simply illiterate requirements, testifies to the low professional level of their initiators. And this is not surprising - a typical person from scientific circles, who has not independently opened a single more or less serious case, Kildyushov, despite his professorial title, has no idea about the real goals, objectives and methods of practical forensic medicine. This is also evidenced by the appointment to the most responsible positions in the bureau of people who are unknown to anyone, who do not enjoy authority among the employees, but who are clearly promoted by someone. In this case, the principle of personnel selection becomes not the professionalism of the candidate, but his “loyalty,” by which Kildushov means full support of his policy aimed at the collapse of the Bureau’s infrastructure and denunciation of his fellow workers for any reason.

It is quite obvious that the activities of the head of the Bureau of Forensic Medicine leads to the inevitable destruction of the system created by generations of Moscow forensic experts, and a further loss of the authority of Moscow forensic medicine among law enforcement officers and colleagues - doctors of other specialties. And all this is happening against the backdrop of complete indifference of the parent organization - the capital’s health department. While officials are inactive, experts and orderlies, at the instigation of Kildushov, are forced to become undertakers.

After the publication of this article, most likely, employees of the SME Bureau will be subjected to even greater repression and harassment from the administration, and possibly even dismissal, so the phrase suggests itself - all characters are fictitious, all coincidences are random. Hang in there, Bureau employees!

See the original material on the “Top Secret” website:

Doctor of Medical Sciences, Professor.

Born on August 19, 1967 in a family of teachers. In 1984, after graduating from high school, he entered the 2nd Moscow Medical Institute (now RNRMU) named after. N.I. Pirogov. In 1986-1988 completed active service in the border troops on the southern borders of the USSR, after which, until 1992, he continued his studies at the university.

In 1995, he completed full-time graduate school and defended his thesis “Forensic medical criteria for pelvic injuries in children when exposed to blunt objects from the front (mechanisms, biomechanics, diagnostics).”

Since 1995 - assistant of the department, since 2002 - associate professor, and since 2007 - professor of the department of the Russian National Research Medical University named after. N.I. Pirogov..

In 2005, he defended his doctoral dissertation “Modeling the post-mortem heat transfer process as a method for diagnosing the age of death of a newborn.” In 2012, he was awarded the academic title of professor. From 1997 to 2008 he taught forensic medicine at the Moscow Institute of Medical and Social Rehabilitation, from 2001 to 2008 he headed the educational part of the department.

In 2012, he was appointed chief freelance specialist in forensic medical examination of the Moscow Health Department and headed the Bureau of Forensic Medical Examination of the Moscow Health Department.

In 2014, he returned to the Russian National Research Medical University and headed the Department of Forensic Medicine.

Co-author of the Workshop (1998, 2003, 2005, 2007) and a textbook on forensic medicine for medical universities (2012), collections of situational tasks in forensic medicine for independent work of students and final control (2011), textbooks “Forensic Medicine” (2004, 2006, 2008, 2010) for students studying in legal specialties, “Guide to forensic medicine for students in the specialty “forensic medical examination” (2014, 2016, 2017), national guide “Forensic medicine and forensic medical examination” (2014).

Member of the Dissertation Councils of the Federal State Budgetary Institution "Russian Center for Forensic Medicine" of the Ministry of Health of Russia and the Moscow State Medical and Dental University named after. A.I. Evdokimova, member of the Profile Commission of the Expert Council in the field of healthcare of the Ministry of Health of Russia in the specialty “forensic medical examination”, member of the editorial board of the journal “Forensic Medical Examination”.

He was awarded a Certificate of Honor from the Moscow Ministry of Health, a medal from the Russian Ministry of Emergency Situations “For the Commonwealth in the Name of Salvation,” and a medal from the Russian Ministry of Defense “For Strengthening the Combat Commonwealth.”

last information update: 03/24/2019 17:35

Career in Forensic Medicine

2012-2014 - professor. Department of Forensic Medicine

2014-present - head department. Department of Forensic Medicine. State Budgetary Educational Institution of Higher Professional Education Russian National Research Medical University named after. N.I.Pirogov Ministry of Health and Social Development of Russia

Personalities

Evgeny Mikhailovich Kildushov. To the 50th anniversary of his birth // Forensic medical examination. - M., 2017. - No. 4. — P. 64-65.

Information about publications on the site

Mechanogenesis of pelvic fractures in children depending on the angle of external influence / Kildyushov E.M. // Mater. IV All-Russian. Congress of Forensic Physicians: abstracts of reports. - Vladimir, 1996. - No. 1. — P. 98-99.

On the separation of functions of an expert institution and a funeral organization / Nikolaev B.S., Kildyushov E.M. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2000. - No. 1.

On the thermometry of a corpse / Kildushov E.M. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2000. - No. 4. — P. 3.

On the principles of constructing a mathematical model for studying the process of cooling the corpse of a newborn / Kildyushov E.M., Mukhai A.N. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2000. - No. 5. — P. 3.

Forensic medical examination (research) of corpses of fetuses and newborns: Textbook / Kachina N.N., Kildyushov E.M. — 2003.

Establishing the duration of death when examining a corpse at the place of its discovery - problems and solutions / Kildyushov E.M., Kryukov V.N. // Mat. VI All-Russian Congress of Forensic Physicians. - M.-Tyumen, 2005.

On the problem of diagnosing acute intoxication with ethyl alcohol in expert practice / Kildyushov E.M., Buromsky I.V., Kriger O.V. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2007. - No. 2.

Dynamics of postmortem changes in intraocular pressure as a possible way to determine the duration of death / Sokolova Z.Yu., Kildyushov E.M. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2007. - No. 3.

Proposals for standardization of terminology used in assessing the quality of medical care / Buromsky I.V., Kildyushov E.M. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2007. - No. 3.

On the need for a unified approach to examining a corpse at the site of its discovery / Sokolova Z.Yu., Butovsky I.D., Kildyushov E.M. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2007. - No. 5.

Forensic medical examination of the corpses of fetuses and newborns: Textbook / Bashkireva E.A., Buromsky I.V., Kachina N.N., Kildyushov E.M., Klimova O.Yu., Kryukov V.N., Nikolaev B. S.S., Plaksin V.O., Solokhin Yu.A., Shabalina T.N. — 2007.

Forensic medical assessment of myoglobin content in blood and urine in certain types of fatal poisoning / Papyshev I.P., Chernyaev A.L., Samsonova M.V., Kildyushov E.M., Obernikhin S.S., Mikhaleva L.M. . // Selected issues of forensic medical examination. - Khabarovsk, 2009. - No. 10. - pp. 93-95.

Expert assessment of stab wounds of the skin exposed to water / Sidorenko E.S., Kildyushov E.M. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2010. - No. 2. — P. 7-9.

Forensic medical thanatology / Tumanov E.V., Kildyushov E.M., Sokolova Z.Yu. — 2011.

On the legality of establishing the fact of a newborn child based on an examination of his corpse / Kildyushov E.M., Buromsky I.V., Nikishtsev I.N., Bashkireva E.A., Sokolova Z.Yu., Tumanov E.V. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2011. - No. 2. — P. 53-56.

Diagnosis of the duration of death by thermometric method in the early postmortem period (New medical technology) / Kildyushov E.M., Vavilov A.Yu., Kulikov V.A. — 2011.

Diagnosis of the duration of death by thermometric method (In the early postmortem period) / Kildyushov E.M., Vavilov A.Yu. — 2011.

Diagnosis of the duration of death by thermometric method in the early postmortem period (new medical technology) / Kildyushov E.M., Vavilov A.Yu., Kulikov V.A. // Bulletin of Forensic Medicine. - Novosibirsk, 2012. - No. 1. — P. 19-22.

Substantiation of a mathematical model of the process of postmortem recovery of a spin probe for diagnosing the duration of death / Ermakova Yu.V., Kildyushov M.S., Kildyushov E.M., Reznikov I.I. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2012. - No. 2. — P. 22-24.

Theories of the development of rigor mortis: history and original concept / Kildyushov E.M., Tumanov E.V., Sokolova Z.Yu. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2012. - No. 3. — P. 48-51.

Scientific and practical conference with international participation “Current issues of forensic medicine and medical law”, dedicated to the memory of Professor V.O. Plaksina / Kildyushov E.M., Barinov E.Kh. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2012. - No. 3. — P. 67.

Forensic medicine: textbook / Pigolkin Yu.I., Romodanovsky P.O., Kildyushov E.M., Dubrovin I.A., Sundukov D.V. — 2012.

7th Scientific and Practical Conference of Young Scientists and Specialists with International Participation of the Moscow Society of Forensic Physicians “Forensic Medical Science and Practice” / Kovalev A.V., Kildyushov E.M., Barinov E.Kh., Makarov I.Yu. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2013. - No. 1. — P. 65-66.

Historical aspects of the participation of a medical specialist in the field of forensic medicine in examining a corpse at the place of its discovery / Butovsky D.I., Isaeva L.M., Kildyushov E.M., Sokolova Z.Yu., Kubarev A.A. // Medical expertise and law. - 2013. - No. 1. — P. 49.

Case of injury from atmospheric electricity / Kildyushov E.M., Barinov E.Kh., Skrebnev A.V., Romodanovsky P.O. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2013. - No. 2. — P. 44-46.

Vishnevsky spots: history of discovery and modern theories of occurrence (analytical review) / Tumanov E.V., Kildyushov E.M. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2015. - No. 3. — P. 52-57.

Fatal injury from technical electricity from a mobile device (phone) connected to the network / Rudenko I.A., Kildyushov E.M., Kodarova E.M., Morozov V.Yu., Fetisov V.A. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2015. - No. 5. — P. 62-64.

Monitoring the incidence of HIV infection according to forensic medical examination data in Moscow / Kildyushov E.M., Kovalev A.V., Morozov Yu.E., Mazus A.I., Serebryakov E.M., Kudimov I.N., Kadochnikov D.S., Minaeva P.V. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2015. - No. 5. — P. 4-8.

Forensic, social and gender aspects of suicide death / Pigolkin Yu.I., Kildyushov E.M., Shilova M.A., Globa I.V., Boeva S.E. // Bulletin of Forensic Medicine. - Novosibirsk, 2016. - No. 1. — P. 9-14.

Forensic medical characteristics of sudden death in oncological pathology / Pigolkin Yu.I., Kildyushov E.M., Shilova M.A., Boeva S.E., Zakharov S.N., Globa I.V. // Bulletin of Forensic Medicine. - Novosibirsk, 2016. - No. 2. — P. 8-11.

Forensic medical characteristics of the causes of sudden death in young people / Pigolkin Yu.I., Shilova M.A., Kildyushov E.M., Galchikov Yu.I. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2016. - No. 5. — P. 4-9.

Forensic medical diagnosis of HIV infection taking into account the results of epidemiological monitoring / Kildyushov E.M., Morozov Yu.E., Kudimov I.N. // Forensic Medicine. - 2016. - No. 1. — P. 25-30.

Modeling of ricochet when fired from small arms / Gusentsov A.O., Chuchko V.A., Kildyushov E.M., Tumanov E.V. // Forensic-medical examination. - M., 2017. - No. 2. — P. 14-17.

Diagnosis of the duration of death in the late postmortem period in forensic medical practice (literature review) / Kildyushov E.M., Ermakova Yu.V., Tumanov E.V., Kuznetsova G.S. // Forensic Medicine. - 2018. - No. 1. — P. 34-38.

Dissertations

Kildyushov E.M. Forensic medical criteria for pelvic injuries in children when exposed to blunt objects from the front (mechanisms, biomechanics, diagnostics): dis. Ph.D. honey. Sci. - M., 1995.
Kildyushov E.M. Modeling the post-mortem heat transfer process as a method for diagnosing the age of death of a newborn: dis. doc. honey. Sci. - M., 2005.

Bibliography

Kildyushov E.M., Ermakova Yu.V., Tumanov E.V., Kuznetsova G.S. Diagnosis of the duration of death in the late postmortem period in forensic medical practice (literature review) // Forensic medicine. - 2018. - No. 1. - P. 34-38.

Gusentsov A.O., Chuchko V.A., Kildyushov E.M., Tumanov E.V. Modeling of ricochet when fired from small arms // Forensic medical examination. - 2017. - No. 2. - P. 14-17.

Kildyushov E.M., Morozov Yu.E., Kudimov I.N. Forensic medical diagnosis of HIV infection taking into account the results of epidemiological monitoring // Forensic medicine. - 2016. - No. 1. - P. 25-30.
Pigolkin Yu.I., Kildyushov E.M., Shilova M.A., Boeva S.E., Zakharov S.N., Globa I.V. Forensic medical characteristics of sudden death in oncological pathology // Bulletin of Forensic Medicine. - Novosibirsk, 2016. - No. 2. - P. 8-11.
Pigolkin Yu.I., Kildyushov E.M., Shilova M.A., Globa I.V., Boeva S.E. Forensic, social and gender aspects of suicide death // Bulletin of Forensic Medicine. - Novosibirsk, 2016. - No. 1. - P. 9-14.
Pigolkin Yu.I., Shilova M.A., Kildyushov E.M., Galchikov Yu.I. Forensic medical characteristics of the causes of sudden death in young people // Forensic medical examination. - 2016. - No. 5. - P. 4-9.

Kildyushov E.M., Kovalev A.V., Morozov Yu.E., Mazus A.I., Serebryakov E.M., Kudimov I.N., Kadochnikov D.S., Minaeva P.V. Monitoring the incidence of HIV infection according to forensic medical examination data in Moscow // Forensic medical examination. - 2015. - No. 5. — P. 4-8.
Rudenko I.A., Kildyushov E.M., Kodarova E.M., Morozov V.Yu., Fetisov V.A. Fatal injury from technical electricity from a mobile device (phone) connected to the network // Forensic medical examination. - 2015. - No. 5. — P. 62-64.
Tumanov E.V., Kildyushov E.M. Vishnevsky's spots: history of discovery and modern theories of occurrence (analytical review) // Forensic medical examination. - 2015. - No. 3. — P. 52-57.

Kildyushov E.M., Barinov E.Kh., Skrebnev A.V., Romodanovsky P.O. Case of injury from atmospheric electricity // Forensic medical examination. - 2013. - No. 2. — P. 44-46.
Kovalev A.V., Kildyushov E.M., Barinov E.Kh., Makarov I.Yu. 7th scientific and practical conference of young scientists and specialists with international participation of the Moscow Society of Forensic Physicians “Forensic medical science and practice” // Forensic medical examination. - 2013. - No. 1. — P. 65-66.

Buromsky I.V., Kildyushov E.M. Point-rating system for assessing learning outcomes in forensic medicine // Forensic medical examination. - 2012. - No. 3. - pp. 56-59.
Ermakova Yu.V., Kildyushov M.S., Kildyushov E.M., Reznikov I.I. Justification of a mathematical model of the process of postmortem recovery of a spin probe for diagnosing the duration of death // Forensic medical examination. - 2012. - No. 2. - pp. 22-24.
Kildyushov E.M., Barinov E.Kh. Scientific and practical conference with international participation “Current issues of forensic medicine and medical law”, dedicated to the memory of Professor V.O. Plaksina // Forensic medical examination. - 2012. - No. 3. - P. 67.
Kildyushov E.M., Tumanov E.V., Sokolova Z.Yu. Theories of the development of rigor mortis: history and original concept // Forensic medical examination. - 2012. - No. 3. - P. 48-51.
Forensic medical assessment of changes in a corpse in the state of fat wax // Current issues of forensic medicine and medical law. Materials of the scientific and practical conference with international participation, dedicated to the memory of Professor V.O. Plaksina. - M.: NP IC "YurInfoZdrav", 2012. - P. 285 - 290.
Tumanov E.V., Kildyushov E.M., Sokolova Z.Yu. Forensic thanatology. // - Moscow: NP IC "YurInfoZdrav", - 2012. -172 p.

Kildyushov E.M., Buromsky I.V., Nikishtsev I.N., Bashkireva E.A., Sokolova Z.Yu., Tumanov E.V. On the legality of establishing the fact of a newborn child on the basis of an examination of his corpse // Forensic medical examination. - 2011. - No. 2. - P. 53-56.
Kildyushov E.M., Tumanov E.V., Sokolova Z.Yu., Ershakova Yu.V., Kubarev A.A., Nikishtsev I.N., Parilov S.L., Chikun V.I. Using applied mathematics methods to model and identify various processes in forensic practice. // Morphology of critical and terminal conditions. Materials of a scientific-practical conference with international participation - M.: NP IC "YurInfoZdrav", 2011. - P. 76-79.
Tumanov E.V., Kildyushov E.M., Sokolova Z.Yu., Kubarev A.A. Forensic medical significance of post-mortem drying of a corpse // Current issues of forensic medicine and medical law. Materials of the scientific and practical conference with international participation, dedicated to the memory of Professor V.O. Plaksina. - M.: NP IC "YurInfoZdrav", 2011. - P. 279 - 285.
Tumanov E.V., Kildyushov E.M., Sokolovav Z.Yu. Questions of mathematical modeling of blunt cardiac trauma // Morphology of critical and terminal conditions. Materials of a scientific-practical conference with international participation - M.: NP IC "YurInfoZdrav", 2011. - P. 180-184.

Sidorenko E.S., Kildyushov E.M. Expert assessment of stab wounds of the skin exposed to water // Forensic medical examination. - 2010. - No. 2. - P. 7-9.

Papyshev I.P., Chernyaev A.L., Samsonova M.V., Kildyushov E.M., Obernikhin S.S., Mikhaleva L.M. Forensic medical assessment of myoglobin content in blood and urine in certain types of fatal poisoning // Selected issues of forensic medical examination. - Khabarovsk, 2009. - Issue 10. - pp. 93-95.

Golubev N.G., Kildyushov E.M., Petrishchev A.A., Nikolaev B.S., Samoilov M.V., Sokolova Z.Yu., Tumanov E.V. Method of polymer embalming of anatomical preparations. Patent 2402904 for an invention of the Russian Federation // - C1 IPC A01N1/00 2006.01.

Kildyushov E.M., Kryukov V.N. Establishing the duration of death when examining a corpse at the place of its discovery - problems and solutions // Mat. VI All-Russian Congress of Forensic Physicians. - M.-Tyumen, 2005. - No. - WITH. .

Kildyushov E.M., Kildyushov M.S. Determination of the time of death based on rectal thermometry data using numerical methods of calculation on a computer // Forensic medical examination. - M., 2002. - No. 5. — P. 3-5.

Nikolaev B.S., Kildyushov E.M. On the issue of embalming bodies previously subjected to autopsy for forensic research) // Materials of the XIV Plenum of the All-Russian Society of Forensic Physicians. (June 17-18, 1999). - M., 1999. - P. 128-129.

Kildyushov E.M. Establishing the stages of destruction of the pelvic bones under the influence of an impact force from the front // Current issues of forensic medicine and expert practice. - Novosibirsk, 1998. - Issue. 3. - pp. 156-157.
Kildyushov E.M., Plaksin V.O., Chilyukhina N.A., Kriger O.V., Lomovitsky M.S. Analysis of newborn mortality in Moscow for 1997 - 1998 // Prospects for the development and improvement of the forensic medical service of the Russian Federation. (Materials of the 5th All-Russian Congress of Forensic Physicians). - M. - Astrakhan, 2000. - P. 105 - 106.

Kildyushov E.M., Buromsky I.V., Bolomatov N.V., Pankin Yu.A. Analysis of the information content of X-ray and computed tomography studies in the diagnosis of trauma in children // Modern issues of forensic medicine and expert practice. - Izhevsk, 1997. - V. 9. - p. 117 - 120.
Kuznetsov L.E., Anikin Yu.M., Kildyushov E.M., Bortsova T.Yu., Gribakin M.V. Geometric analysis of the structure of the human pelvis // Legal and organizational issues of forensic medicine and expert practice. - Kirov. 1997. - Part 1. - p. 33 - 40.
Kuznetsov L.E., Khokhlov V.V., Kildyushov E.M., Vasin V.E., Baryshev E.K., Shigeev S.V. Force analysis of calculation models of some geometric shapes // Legal and organizational issues of forensic medicine and expert practice. - Kirov, 1997. - part 1. - p. 25032.

Kildyushov E.M. Mechanogenesis of pelvic fractures in children depending on the angle of external influence // Problems of identification in the theory and practice of forensic medicine. Materials of the IV All-Russian Congress of Forensic Physicians. - M. - Vladimir, 1996. - Part 1. - p. 98 - 99.
Kildyushov E.M. The nature and mechanism of pelvic fractures in children when impacted by blunt hard objects in the area of the pubic symphysis at different angles to the plane of the pelvic ring // Forensic medical examination. - M., 1996. No. 3. - p. 16 - 19.
Goniometric indicators of the child’s pelvis // Modern issues of forensic medicine and expert practice. - Izhevsk, 1996. - V. 8. - P. 131 - 137.
Kildyushov E.M., Kuznetsov L.E., Kildyushova E.A. Prospects for creating a biomechanical model of the pelvis using the finite element method // Modern issues of forensic medicine and expert practice. - Izhevsk, 1996 - V. 8. - P. 138 - 144.
Kildyushov E.M., Kuznetsov L.E., Chumakova Yu.V. The nature and mechanogenesis of pelvic bone fractures in children when impacted by blunt hard objects in a diagonal direction from the front to the side // Forensic medical examination. - M., 1996. No. 1. - p. 3 - 6.

You can search for information about other forensic doctors using the catalog below

If you notice an error or want to add information about a person, please contact our forum Forens Ru Once again we thank all the participants of our forum who took part in creating this section and updating it with fresh information.

Who's Who in Forensic Medicine— a section where information about forensic doctors is collected and constantly updated.

If the information is not in our directory, or the information contained is erroneous, outdated, or simply not enough, write to a special section of our forum. We'll definitely fix everything.

Corsicans or Sicilians are considered recognized specialists in bloody types of revenge - but RP columnist Alexander Rokhlin finds irrefutable, medically confirmed evidence that bloodiness is not completely alien to our compatriots.

What was it?

Tragifarce or devilish joke? The boundaries of meaning are blurred, like the facial features of a drowned man. Acting is a dubious pleasure. And I, obviously, watched the theater. This is written on the building too. And in stone letters. The founders were confident that nothing else would ever appear here. So, I saw the play. The action unfolded, admittedly, rather slowly. But very convincing. Yes Yes! Exceptional authenticity combined with incredible lifelessness. How to explain? Very simple.

The actors were...dead. All as one. The identities of some were completely impossible to know, since only fragments of their mortal bodies took part in the drama. You can’t relax here: you are the only living participant in what is happening. As a spectator of what is happening... You quickly understand how easily what is happening could become your sad outcome. Not a single actor in this theater died a natural death, but exclusively by violence. Actually, the whole performance is based on the fact of the death of the performer. Details and nuances. Death at the hands of a neighbor, as a result of accidents, revenge, malicious intent, laying on of hands, blows with blunt objects, piercing objects, poisonous substances and other methods of excluding the living from the book.

So it wasn't a morgue. But anatomical theater. Department of Forensic Medicine, Research University named after. N.I. Pirogov.

A magnificent building, where vaults, arches, doors in the audience, dim corridors, flickering lamps on the walls, flights of stairs with marble steps and forged railings - everything is solemn, ponderous and saturated with bitter experience. Temple of Science. The only temple where theater is appropriate. The only theater where they serve science, not entertainment. A person must feel out of place here. Here, the reasons for his death, the conclusions of posthumous examinations are higher and more important than all his aspirations, passions, mistakes and victories in life.

“...After which the person condemned to death was scourged. For this purpose, they took off his clothes and tied his hands to a pole on the court premises. He was then flogged with a short whip called a flagrum (or flagellum). The whip consisted of a handle, to which leather straps of different lengths were attached, pieces of lead were woven into the ends, and jagged fragments of bones were woven along the length...

Blows with a flagrum were inflicted by one or two executors of punishment (lictors) on the back, buttocks and thighs of the convicted person. They only avoided striking the projection of the heart, because this could lead to premature death. The consequences of such scourging were truly terrifying. In places where the flagrum belts struck, the skin was torn, and the underlying soft tissues were crushed. It is no coincidence that the whip for punishment was sometimes also called flagrum taxillatum - a stinging whip, “a scourge that brings terror.”

At the same time, flagellation, while causing extensive damage to the soft tissues of the back, could not lead to significant blood loss, since it did not damage any large blood vessels. Bleeding from the blood vessels of the skin and subcutaneous fat damaged during the execution was relatively insignificant and stopped fairly soon...”

The building of the Bureau of Forensic Medical Examination of the Moscow Department of Health is regularly visited by citizens. At the entrance they are greeted by security guards who readily answer questions of a reference nature. And it is here, in front of the metal turntable at the entrance and exit, that citizens find themselves in an awkward position. Very characteristic...

They ask the guards: “How to get through the examination?” And the guards patiently ask: “What kind of examination do you want - corpses or living ones?” A simple question, but all the visitors are embarrassed, make surprised eyes, not knowing what to answer, and giggle stupidly. A person is never ready. Neither to trial nor to death. But it is in these two areas that forensic medicine reigns. The word “judicial” is derived not from court, but from fate.

There is also a museum here. My tongue will no longer dare to call this collection of horror and darkness the home of the muses. In the latter, you can at least laugh at mothballs. Exhibits living in the world of forensic medicine only cause convulsions. And convulsive grimaces. One question. How was the damage caused? Killed? How? And over what period of time? And here are the answers: knives, knives, sharpenings, blades, rods, awls, screwdrivers, files, chisels. And the handles are carved, inlaid, mother-of-pearl...

No... That's not what it's all about. There's an old lady living here in the closet! The convulsions begin. Mom dear! Just think about it... The old woman lives in the closet - a figure of speech. Because the “old woman” is a corpse, one hundred percent, beyond doubt, but to such a degree of preservation that if you don’t know... It’s like a living thing! She lives, in the sense of abides, causing a strong emotional reaction upon meeting. Not for the faint of heart or impressionable. Skin, hair, bones, internal organs - everything is natural, our own. There are holes in the eyes, a grin in the teeth, but there is a gold ring on the finger. Grimace of Death; crooked life. This death has been living in a museum cabinet since 1963. And before that, for another twenty years she “lived” on the mezzanine in a Moscow apartment, in Meshchanskaya Sloboda. The forensic medical examination in a laconic certificate says that citizen N. lived in her natural state and was healthy until she died in 1942. And her sister, who occupied a common living space with her, decided to temporarily hide the fact of death in order to use food cards for two. And she hid it... The amazing thing is that the deceased in the most incredible way avoided rotting. Science is unable to explain and only states. The old woman from Meshchanskaya simply dried up like an autumn leaf. Strictly speaking, she was mummified. Without outside help. Remember Lenin! How much effort and money he requires from his descendants, but here everything is for free...

After some time, the greedy sister removed the corpse on the mezzanine and... forgot about it. This turned out to be easy: with a height of 150 cm, the weight of the mummy sister is only 4 kg 100 grams. Thus, this “living” corpse continues to exist. And work on the history of forensic medicine. As a monument to the wonders of human cruelty and stupidity.

Extract from the forensic medical examination, which... did not happen

“In order for the crucified person to remain alive on the cross for as long as possible and thus prolong the victim’s torment, the Romans used various devices that provided some support for the victim’s body (this may explain the phrase “sitting on the cross” used by the Romans). For this purpose, a small ledge, or seat (sedile), was sometimes used, which was placed on the staticulum in such a way that this seat passed between the legs of the convicted person. To increase the suffering of the victim, the seat was sometimes made pointed. Instead of a seat, sometimes they made a support for the legs in the form of a plate (pedale, or suppedaneum) nailed to the bottom of the staticulum, which was less painful than being on a pointed seat, but also prolonged the suffering of the convict. In both of these cases, the crucified person, rather, did not hang on the cross, but sat or stood, nailed to it...

After conducting a series of experiments with amputated arms, as well as with corpses, P. Barbet discovered facts that were unexpected at that time. It turned out that when nailed to the cross at the level of the middle of the palms, the hands were torn from the nails with a load of about 39 kg (88 lbs). Experimental data confirmed mathematical calculations, which showed that in a position on the cross, during which the arms of the person being crucified move away from the body to the patibulum at an angle close to 68°, the body of the condemned person will definitely fall off the cross.

Looking for an anatomical place that could, on the one hand, most fully correspond to the Gospel text and historical chronicles, and on the other hand, reliably hold the weight of the crucified person on nails, P. Barbet came to the conclusion that the Desto space on the wrist is most suitable for this (Destot).

If the nail was driven into Desto's space located between the triquetral, capitate and hamate bones of the wrist, the hands of the crucified person were securely held on the cross, regardless of his body weight. An important circumstance was also the fact that when nails pass through Desto’s space, bleeding from pierced wrists is relatively insignificant, since this does not damage large main blood vessels.”

Evgeny Mikhailovich Kildushov knows more about revenge than other people. Did he take revenge? Did they take revenge on him? Let's leave it behind the scenes... He heads the Bureau of Forensic Medicine and the Department of the same medicine at Pirogov University. He is a doctor, an expert and a boss. A very balanced person. An exceptionally informed person. From him I will hear:

“Revenge is war. And war is death. Forensic medicine knows more about it than others..."

In his office hangs a copy of the portrait of the Russian doctor Minakov. One of the founding fathers of the department. Take a close look. The doctor - very similar to Chekhov - sits in deep thought... Of course! In his hands is a human skull. Why did he die? Was there any violence? How to prove?

“The medical examiner knows everything. But it's too late."

Note from Dr. Kildushov.

It's too late for the deceased or deceased. Who personally doesn’t care anymore. But it's never too late for history. Which is eternal. This is the uniqueness of science. Remember the first trial in which the judgment of a medical expert led to a guilty verdict. The case of Madame Lafargue, accused of poisoning her husband in 1840.

Remember the English king Charles the Second, who dabbled in alchemy and experiments with mercury... He died in the seventeenth century, the reasons became clear in the twentieth. Let us remember our sworn “friend” Napoleon Bonaparte, whose death from arsenic was confirmed by chemists 150 years later. And don’t forget that unfortunate person whose head in the portrait is held in the hands of Doctor Minakov. He died from a blow... from a bear's paw. And his skull, a century later, bears traces of the last meeting.

“Forensic medicine does not judge. She only knows the truth..."

This is her second exceptional quality. Don't judge. Hence such balance in Evgeniy Mikhailovich’s reasoning. He doesn't say unnecessary words. It’s as if they are not in his vocabulary.

“Forensic medicine understands the frailty of existence better than others... Man is an extremely resilient and at the same time fragile creature.” And the best confirmation of the words of the chief forensic expert of Moscow is the unique university collection of perishable, fragile, persistent and somewhere even extra-existent (that is, beyond the boundaries of good and evil) human material.

From here begins the very theater where there is no smell of acting, there is no smell of anything at all. Here you feel a strange emptiness, not at all mysterious, but attractive. This is how the flight of stairs attracts you from the height of the tenth floor. It seems that demons are fluttering in flocks behind your back. Suddenly you remember: “Revenge is the daughter of stupidity. You can ignore both if it weren’t for the deadly consequences”...

And then, in front of the glass display cases with “perishable exhibits,” your knees get unpleasantly cold.

Extract from the forensic medical examination, which... did not happen

“In order to shorten the time of torment of those crucified on the cross, there was a custom of crurifragium (skelokopia), which was used in cases where, for some reason, a decision was made to speed up the death of the condemned.

During the scalocopy, the bones of the legs were broken with a crucified hammer, after which the body of the convict was deprived of a fulcrum and hung from his arms. Under these conditions, overstretching of the chest quickly occurred and suffocation occurred much faster - within several tens of minutes or even faster.

This position was convincingly proven by K-S.D. Schulte, who in a series of controlled experiments on volunteers showed that if crucifixion occurred only by hanging on the hands, without support on the legs, then in all subjects, already at the 6th minute, the volume of inhaled air decreased by approximately 70%, blood pressure dropped by 50% of normal, and the heart rate doubled. After 12 minutes, breathing was carried out only due to the movements of the diaphragm and loss of consciousness occurred.

When the volunteers were allowed to periodically (once for 20 seconds) lean on their feet during crucifixion, there was a pronounced normalization of the activity of the cardiovascular system and breathing. The experiment in the latter case lasted up to 30–40 minutes, after which the subjects experienced severe pain in the wrists and the experiment was stopped.

P. Barbet’s theory that the death of those condemned to crucifixion occurred as a result of positional asphyxia, caused by the position of the body of the person being crucified on the cross, seems quite convincing, providing a reasonable explanation for the onset of death in people being crucified, and is currently accepted by almost all researchers.

However, while paying tribute to the pioneering work of P. Barbet, it should still be recognized that, having revealed the peculiarities of death during crucifixion, he was never able to adequately explain one specific case - the death of Jesus Christ on the cross.”

I saw a collection of stomachs poisoned with sulfuric, carbolic, nitric acids, caustic soda, sublimate, and formaldehyde. A mind-blowing sight!

Dummies, but made from real human material. That is, these were stomachs that belonged to people who had the misfortune of being poisoned or poisoned. The color scheme was amazing. Green, crimson, yellow, purple and brown stomachs looked at me from behind the glass.

Following the stomachs, in the same variety of colors, came poisoned esophaguses, intestines, ruined lungs, torn hearts and livers, abscessed brains, crushed faces, fingers, severed heads and other parts of people marked by violence. Each of them was "voiced" with a blatant monologue - a short note (in an elegant font with curlicues) characterizing the case. As if these were greeting cards, and not post-mortem examination findings. I read them, and the hair on my head should have moved...

“Facial skin during self-poisoning with caustic alkali.”

"Spontaneous cardiac rupture."

"Forehead fractures."

"Compression of a block of earth."

“Fatal wounds from an accidental fall on a knife (butcher, 62 years old).”

"Lieutenant Petrov's boots with traces of compression by a passenger train on October 25, 1947."

“Citizen S., who had suffered for a long time from osteomyelitis of the bones in the area of the left wrist joint, cut off with an ax first his 5th finger at the level of the middle part of the metacarpal bone, and then his hand at the level of the wrist joint...”

And simply: the hands and head of a Papuan, the hands of a tiller, a cook, a shoemaker, a cutter.

And a completely incredible exhibit - the face of a dead man with a sign: “Formation of adipose wax. Staying in a coffin for 54 years..."

The topic of our lecture today is positional asphyxia. We must admit that of all the types of asphyxia that we know... By the way, how many?

The interns were silent, and the lecturer quickly listed them from memory...

So, of all the types of asphyxia in the Soviet Union, one type has never been studied, being banned... And this is positional asphyxia. The “oblivion” is related to the fact that the most famous case of positional asphyxia in history immediately led us to whom? That’s right,” the assistant professor continued, although none of the students opened their mouths, “to the crucifixion of Jesus Christ.” Somehow it was not in the hands of an atheistic state to delve into the details of the death of the Lord God...

The assistant professor smiled. But the interns didn’t move; they didn’t understand the joke.

And why? - Associate Professor Tumanov asked with a sad smile. - But because the conclusions of the science of death fit too easily into the text of the Gospel...

Tumanov paused. I took a breath and don’t remember how I breathed anymore. Because it was the most incredible and merciless preaching of Christianity that I have ever heard in my life. Incredible, because the science of death knows no sentiment. Merciless because it left no doubt.

What Kildyushov spoke sparingly and briefly about - for forensic medicine there is no prescription of time - I felt on my own skin. Tumanov gave the lecture as if he himself was conducting an examination of the body of Jesus Christ. And we were present.

The grimaces of death grinned at us from behind the glass cabinets, but the intoxicating emptiness disappeared, erased, like a stupid joke is erased from memory.

Kildushov said that forensic medicine does not judge anyone, but knows the truth.

All the more valuable is this only truth...

Why did Jesus Christ die?

And what does domestic forensic medicine say about this?

Extract from the forensic medical examination, which... did not happen

“Summarizing the above, we can quite reasonably assume that the death of Jesus Christ occurred as a result of the development of disseminated intravascular coagulation syndrome. Most likely in the hypercoagulation phase...

DIC syndrome is an acquired pathology of the blood coagulation system, which is characterized by impaired blood circulation at the level of the microvasculature in vital organs (liver, kidneys, adrenal glands, lungs, etc.). Developing in many cases of acute conditions, including injuries, disseminated intravascular coagulation syndrome can occur within several hours and cause extremely high mortality in victims...

The circumstances that caused the development of this pathological condition were flagellation with extensive damage to the soft tissues of the back and their further traumatization, which occurred both while carrying the cross and while standing on it during the crucifixion. Additional conditions that determined the development of disseminated intravascular coagulation syndrome were increasing hypoxia due to difficulty breathing, increasing hypovolemia as a result of blood loss and dehydration, unnatural position of the body on the cross, a flow of pain from extremities pierced by nails and severe psycho-emotional shock.

“...And he who saw it bore witness, and his testimony is true; he knows that he speaks the truth, so that you may believe” (John 19:34-35).”

The note uses excerpts from an article by Associate Professor E.V. Tumanov “Death by crucifixion. The view of a forensic expert."

Moscow morgues have recently increasingly resembled the private estates of the head of the capital’s forensic medical examination bureau, Evgeny Kildushov. Dubious personalities constantly work around them, the registration of corpses is carried out on a paid basis, and personnel issues are resolved as if the mortuary staff were serfs of Mr. Kildushov. How did this situation come about?

Evgeny Mikhailovich Kildyushov came to Moscow from the provinces and entered the Second Medical Institute. After graduating from this university, he was able to successfully build his own career by marrying a girl from a family of old Moscow doctors, one might say - the medical elite. But, having quickly climbed the career ladder and received the title of Doctor of Science, already respected and fairly well-known in medical circles, Evgeniy Mikhailovich leaves his family and unexpectedly marries again. His new chosen one was a young employee of the Department of Forensic Medicine of the Second Medical Center, where by that time he was working as a director. The young wife predictably quickly becomes an assistant professor in the same department.

But the real blossoming of Kildyushov’s career came in 2012, when he assumed the post of head of the Moscow Forensic Bureau. Here Evgeniy Mikhailovich clearly shows how you can quickly and easily go over the heads of those around you, neglecting the laws of conscience and finding loopholes for enrichment.

The Bureau of Forensic Medicine is engaged in difficult and important work - it examines the bodies of the deceased, identifies the causes of death of victims in murders, accidents and sudden deaths. The results of this work are necessary for investigative authorities, the police, as well as grief-stricken relatives, so research must be carried out with high quality and at an appropriate professional level. The Bureau is in charge of all judicial morgues in Moscow. This is the kind of institution that Evgeniy Mikhailovich runs.

Historically, each of the 11 districts of Moscow had its own branch of the bureau - a morgue, to which the bodies of the dead were delivered from all over the district. Since the Medical Examiner's Office receives approximately 25,000 bodies each year, each county morgue has specialized city funeral services. But in 2010, on the territory of the Southern Administrative District, in the industrial zone at Tarny Proezd, 3, a huge Tsaritsyno morgue was built. Gradually, the bodies of the dead began to be redistributed into it not only in the south of the capital, but also in its other districts.

Since 2014, the funeral service in the Tsaritsyno department has been liquidated, and it has been replaced by dubious individuals who spend all their time near the reception desks and proudly call themselves Help-Ritual LLC. They literally pounce on the relatives of the victims and force them to fill out funeral documents through their organization. In addition to the sale of ritual supplies and funeral arrangements, Help-Ritual also provides services for embalming the bodies of the dead, their sanitary and cosmetic treatment, although the main contingent of employees of this “office” are people who are not related to the provision of funeral services - former carriers of the deceased and morgue orderlies. But employees of the Bureau of Forensic Medicine strongly recommend that relatives of the victims turn to them, and not to real professionals in the ritual market.

It would seem, what does Kildushov have to do with it? Everything is very simple - the bodies of the victims do not leave the territory of the Tsaritsyno morgue until they are released to their relatives. Maybe the employees of the funeral company embalm them on the territory of the morgue legally? But where, in this case, is the corresponding lease agreement, where are the payments for the use of government premises? Neither payments nor contracts simply exist in nature, and embalming and other services for preparing the deceased are performed by full-time orderlies of the Bureau, doing this during their working hours and for a government salary. Help Ritual agents can only fill their pockets with money received for the work of orderlies.

But this is not enough for respected Evgeny Mikhailovich - he decided to use his official position to provide Help-Ritual with work at the expense of other areas of Moscow. Now the bodies of the dead from Arbat, Taganka, Cheryomushki, Vostochny Izmailovo and Ramenki are brought to Tsaritsyno. How much does the economic component prevail over common sense and compassion for relatives if the head of the forensic bureau ignores the additional costs of transporting bodies to a distant morgue, and the suffering of people forced to travel across the city to see their loved ones off on their last journey.

Moreover, recently Mr. Kildushov has begun to think about closing those Moscow morgues where he is unable to place employees of Help-Ritual LLC. There is no other way to explain his unexpected appearances in these morgues. After hours, with a camera in his hands, he looks for evidence that these morgues, which just a month ago met all the necessary requirements, suddenly suddenly no longer meet them.

Meanwhile, thanks to Kildyushov’s “commercial” activities and the increased workload at the Tsaritsyno morgue, the quality of research and expert work there begins to suffer. With the advent of Evgeniy Mikhailovich, staff turnover has sharply increased; strong professionals are forced out of work using harsh methods - wage reduction, rotation and the creation of impossible conditions for normal work. As a result, in 2013 alone, the deputy was forced to resign. in economics Arbuzov R.Yu., head of the personnel department Pashovkina N.N., head of the supply department Shafikov F.E., chief engineer Galoyan V.V., chief accountant Simonova V.N., head of the bidding department Fadeev A.S., head of the supply department Chasova O.V., head of the organizational and methodological department Kochayan A.L., chief nurse Pomanskaya E.V., head of the legal department Nekrasov A.G., head of the planning and economic department Vozhzhova N.A., head of the bidding department Ponomareva M. IN. and many other doctors and laboratory technicians.

Why did you need to get rid of employees who know their job well and are dedicated to it? The answer is simple - all those who could have prevented the Bureau from becoming the personal feeding trough of a resourceful official were left behind.

However, the closure of a number of morgues and personnel losses may also have a prolonged negative effect associated with the training of medical students in clinical departments. Future doctors were deprived of the opportunity to study their profession in full and improve practical skills during training. What future awaits our healthcare with this approach?

But let’s leave aside questions related to the mechanism for a state institution to capture the market for funeral services in Moscow, and briefly dwell on another banal fact - theft from the state treasury. Their scheme is primitive - inflating the initial prices of auctions, guaranteed victory of “their” firms in competitions, and activating uncompleted work as completed in full.

Examples include auctions for the supply of anti-plague suits, in which the initial price was inflated by at least twice, and budget losses amounted to hundreds of thousands of rubles. Ensuring victories in tenders for the companies Alarm-911 LLC, Sfera LLC, related to Kildushov’s deputy for economic work, O.A. Doronina. Signing acts of completion of work to create a unified computer network between departments of the bureau, although such a network has not yet been created. And that's not all cases.

But one-time enrichments from the state treasury do not suit Kildushov, who decides, taking advantage of his position and position, to become an unofficial businessman. The head of the bureau turns his attention to the sphere of funeral services, since he already has considerable experience in this area, and Help-Ritual LLC is rapidly developing under his auspices.

What lies ahead? Concentration of 25,000 dead bodies in the Tsaritsyno morgue? Transport collapse in the industrial zone in Tarny Proezd, where is it located? A mockery of grief-stricken people standing in huge lines for the bodies of their loved ones? Endless trips of police officers to obtain the necessary documents instead of working to protect citizens? What kind of quality of examinations can we even talk about if experts have to work in two shifts?

It is clear that Help-Ritual LLC is just a tool for making money, a ploy that allows Kildyushov to resolve his personal financial issues and, taking advantage of his official position, to use his employees for this. But how can you find out whether the whole system is rotting or just specific people in it? Evgeny Mikhailovich, will you or those who stand behind you answer?

P.S. While the material for this article was being collected, by the sole decision of Mr. Kildushov, another department was closed - morgue No. 2, the work of which will now be carried out by the Tsaritsyno department. Which department is next?

The “Godfather” of the funeral business has the whole of Moscow in his fist

Andrey Petrov